REPUBLICAN
VS.
DEMOCRAT
PHILOSOPHIES
written by National Federation Of Republican Women
Fundamental Beliefs
Within the two major political parties, sharp differences
exist on the specifics of various national and local issues. This
occasionally causes people to wonder what holds Republicans and Democrats
together--what prevents fragmentation into innumerable splinter parties.
The answer is that the two party system relies on
adherence to fundamental beliefs. As an American voter, you should
examine these philosophical principles carefully.
The main theme of Democrat philosophy is the expansion
of the "general welfare" clause of the Constitution to bring within the
scope of the powers of the Federal Government everything interpreted as
dealing with the general welfare of the people. The New Deal, the
Fair Deal, New Frontier, and Great Society are all essentially concepts
of federal paternalism--direction and control of the lives of all citizens
from Washington. To implement this philosophy effectively the concept
of three coordinate branches of the Federal Government is rejected in favor
of domination by the Executive.
The Republican philosophy is firmly based upon acceptance
of the concept of restraint of power: 1) the limited, delegated powers
of the Federal Government set forth in the Constitution; 2) the balance
of power among the three coordinate branches of the Federal Government;
3) the freedom of the States and their people to promote their own welfare
within the spirit and letter of the Constitution, with only such assistance
or regulation by the Federal Government as may be necessary in the best
interests of all the people, or essential under the Constitution.
The Two Party System--Room for a Wide Diversity of
Views
The genius, and the long life and success of the
two party system in the United States, is that both great parties have
provided accommodation within their ranks for a wide diversity of views.
This has been possible because both parties agree upon certain objectives,
e.g., the "welfare of the people," but disagree upon the means of reaching
those goals. Thus, when an election brings a change of party in control
of the government, there is not a revolution. The party out
of power becomes the loyal opposition until it again is in the ascendancy.
The function of the minority during this period
is to: 1) point out errors and deficiencies of the party in power;
2) develop and present to the voters the plans and basic beliefs that will
be brought into government if the voters select them [the opposition] to
lead.
Republican Record--Individual Initiative
The long period of Republican leadership saw the
West
settled, transcontinental railroads built, a strong, sound financial system
established, and our natural resources developed. It was a period
of enormous complexity and growth, during which, with few brief interruptions,
the Republican Party guided the Nation. Education, public health,
conservation, banking, recreation, antitrust laws, and maximum development
of strong, responsible government at state and local levels characterized
the major thrusts of Republican efforts.
REPUBLICAN PARTY philosophy is rooted in a belief
in individual rights and responsibilities. Maximum power to determine
their destiny should lie in the hands of the people and governmental power
and resources should be kept close to the people, rather than monopolized
from a distance by officials in Washington, D.C. Local government,
local education and community life belong to the people themselves.
DEMOCRAT administrations have pushed for more and
more centralized power in Washington, with only secondary consideration
for the rights of individuals and communities. This has meant increasingly
tighter federal control and regimentation, often at the hands of unelected
bureaucrats, and an erosion of grassroots government across the country.
It is significant that today some Democrats are
talking more and more of returning to a concept Republicans have never
abandoned--that state and local governments are best suited to solving
our major problems.
For over a hundred years Republican administrations
have kept faith by meeting the Nation's needs without abandoning our basic
belief in the kind of government that permits the greatest flowering of
individual initiative. The Republican Party demonstrated--by performance--government
competence on a high scale, compassion for the interests of all in the
community, the less fortunate as well as those who have prospered under
our free society; and, most of all, Republicans did these things in furtherance
of the belief that the primary purpose of government is to free each individual
to develop the very best that is in him--all of his abilities and talents--so
long as he prevents no one else from doing the same thing. This should
be the goal of government everywhere.
Domestic tranquility and unity are Republican hallmarks.
No shadow of responsibility was attached to the GOP for encouraging, aligning
with, or supporting the dissident forces which divided our country during
the sixties. Our laws provide rules which all must respect, and they
also provide restraint and penalties for those whose behavior is a threat
to the freedom and rights of others.
The preservation of our Nation and the security
of our citizens depend upon the Constitution, the laws and the courts,
and respect for them is the responsibility of every citizen.
Financial Responsibility And Elimination of Over-Government
Democrats promote an economic order dependent upon,
and controlled by, Federal Government planning and regulation. They
embrace as "new" the idea of a powerful central government taking our tax
money to spend in our behalf, and regulating much of our lives. Far
from being "new", this idea is the old European Monarchic idea which our
founders rejected in the beginning. The Democrats believe that government,
given enough money, can solve everything.
Republicans believe in fiscal responsibility, and
a searching scrutiny of every new spending program as to its need and cost.
Democrats plunge into visionary, untested experiments, unmindful of the
danger of inflation as a result of government extravagance and debt, and
unwilling to reassess and adjust the programs to changing times.
Once started, a Democrat program is rarely retrenched.
Foreign Policy
Republicans believe that only a strong America can
remain a free America. Further, Republican philosophy stresses that
it is absolutely essential to maintain a strong national defense posture
in order that we may at all times negotiate from a position of strength,
not weakness, in our continuing efforts toward world peace and friendship.
National security and world respect are matters
with which Republicans are familiar and comfortable. They have been
well understood. Maintaining a strong military posture in a dangerous
world is just good sense. Americans do not feel guilty about being
strong. Republican administrations have sought cooperation with other
countries and have refrained from meddling. These policies have produced
and maintained respect and peace. by contrast, the Democrats have
muddled into conflict all over the world.
The fact remains--in comparing the success of Republican
and Democrat foreign policies--that U.S. involvement in all of the world
conflicts of this century has occurred under Democrat leadership--none
under Republican direction.